Federal documents warn of sweeping implications if ‘digital loonie’ adopted

Internal government documents show Finance Department officials believe there could be sweeping implications for the economy if the Bank of Canada ever issued its own cryptocurrency.

The Bank of Canada has spent years looking at whether to introduce a digital currency, but so far hasn’t seen an immediate need to issue one.

Read more:

Canada’s digital loonie would be greener than Bitcoin, Bank of Canada says

In one briefing note from last January, officials warned Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland that the issuance of a central bank digital currency would entail “wide-reaching implications for the economy, the financial system” and the Bank of Canada’s operations.

The documents also show the central bank held a series of meetings with federal officials over the course of 2020 to gauge the implications of a “digital loonie” on departments and agencies.

Story continues below advertisement

Large swaths of the documents obtained by The Canadian Press under the access-to-information law have been blacked out because the department says they contain sensitive government information.

But what remains suggests some federal concerns about a central bank digital currency, with departments wanting to provide more input before a decision is made.

Click to play video: 'El Salvador becomes 1st country to adapt Bitcoin as legal tender'

El Salvador becomes 1st country to adapt Bitcoin as legal tender

El Salvador becomes 1st country to adapt Bitcoin as legal tender – Sep 7, 2021

The Bank of Canada has upped the pace of its work on a digital currency, mirroring efforts by counterparts in other countries as the COVID-19 pandemic accelerates the transition to a digital economy.

The bank only plans to issue a digital currency if the use of physical bills for transactions plummets and one or more private cryptocurrencies, such as Bitcoin, become widely used in Canada.

The government and central bank have paid more attention to planned stablecoins whose value is less volatile, as the name implies, and are backed by cash and government securities.

Story continues below advertisement

The use in Canada of private cryptocurrencies tied to the American dollar would strain the Bank of Canada’s ability to manage monetary policy for the benefit of the country, said Jeremy Kronick, associate director of research at the C.D. Howe Institute.

Read more:

Why the COVID-19 pandemic highlights Canada’s need for a digital currency

He said the bank needs to incentivize private cryptocurrencies to use the Canadian dollar as a backing.

“The government could quash this thing in a second. The government could just say, ‘forget it, you can’t transact in Canada,”’ said Kronick, who recently co-authored a paper about the merits of a Bank of Canada digital currency.

“I don’t think they want to because there are benefits to the private cryptos that people like, but we want to also maintain that public good function. To do that, I think the (central bank digital currency) is the way to go.”

Research by the central bank suggests the probability of people using Bitcoin is tied to its prevalence — the more people who adopt it, the more likely others will follow suit — as well as how optimistic users feel about Bitcoin’s future.

The paper published in November noted that Bitcoin adoption in Canada remains low at around five per cent. The authors suggest young Canadians may be more likely to use Bitcoin because it is easier for them to purchase the digital currency than to open a formal bank account.

Story continues below advertisement

Click to play video: 'Boulevard of blockchain dreams: El Salvador plans Bitcoin city at base of volcano'

Boulevard of blockchain dreams: El Salvador plans Bitcoin city at base of volcano

Boulevard of blockchain dreams: El Salvador plans Bitcoin city at base of volcano – Nov 23, 2021

The Bank of Canada doesn’t have the legislative authority from Parliament to offer a digital currency, only to design, issue and distribute the bills stuffed inside wallets and handed over a counter.

The Finance Department has looked at legislation linked to a central bank digital currency of CBDC, although one March email noted that no other countries had “deliberately amended legislation” to allow one.

The email noted that even in Sweden, “widely considered to be at the forefront of the movement towards CBDC among advanced economies,” the government is expecting a report late next year on whether the central bank should have the power to issue a digital currency.

How fast Canadian officials move is likely to depend on how quickly major stablecoins roll out, Kronick said. He pointed to Facebook’s planned stablecoin in particular because it would be easily adopted by the social media giant’s users.

Story continues below advertisement

“I would like them to get ahead of it, but governments are notoriously slower-moving until they have to,” Kronick said.

© 2022 The Canadian Press